Dear Zachary: A Letter to a Son About His Father is often regarded as one of the most upsetting documentaries ever made due to its deeply personal and devastating subject matter. The film, directed by Kurt Kuenne, began as a tribute to his murdered best friend, Andrew Bagby, but evolved into something far more heartbreaking. What starts as a heartfelt memorial quickly spirals into a gut-wrenching account of injustice, loss, and unbearable grief. Viewers are taken on an emotional rollercoaster, experiencing firsthand the pain of Andrew’s loved ones as they fight for justice and custody of his son, Zachary.
One of the most harrowing aspects of Dear Zachary is how it blindsides the audience with its shocking twists. While the film initially focuses on celebrating Andrew’s life, it soon delves into the horrifying reality of his murder at the hands of his ex-girlfriend, Shirley Turner. The emotional weight only intensifies when it’s revealed that Turner is pregnant with Andrew’s child, leading to a legal battle that defies belief. The justice system’s failures become agonizingly clear as Turner is allowed to roam free despite the overwhelming evidence against her, leaving the audience in disbelief and anger.
What makes the film so profoundly devastating is its deeply intimate storytelling. Through home videos, interviews, and heartfelt narration, Kuenne immerses viewers in Andrew’s life, making his loss feel incredibly personal. The love and devotion of Andrew’s parents, David and Kate Bagby, are at the heart of the documentary, and their relentless fight to protect Zachary is both inspiring and tragic. Their pain is palpable, and as the film reaches its most gut-wrenching moments, it leaves audiences emotionally shattered.
Unlike many true crime documentaries, Dear Zachary doesn’t just recount events—it makes the viewer feel every ounce of sorrow, rage, and helplessness. The film is a testament to the depths of human suffering, love, and resilience, making it one of the most emotionally taxing yet unforgettable documentaries ever made. Its impact lingers long after the credits roll, leaving many viewers utterly devastated and forever changed.